Trumpeter 1/72 Su 15 Flagon A
KIT #: | 01624 |
PRICE: | $35.95 MSRP, but can be found for less. |
DECALS: | Three options |
REVIEWER: | Jim Pearsall |
NOTES: | Pavla upgrade sets, C72075 –Flagon-A - Canopies and Interior, U72094 – Flagon-A - Correct Vertical Tail, U72095 – Flagon-A – Correct Nose |
HISTORY |
Recognizing
the limitations of the earlier Su-9 and Su-11, the Sukhoi OKB quickly began the
development of a heavily revised and more capable aircraft. A variety of
development aircraft evolved, including the T-49, which shared the fuselage of
the Su-9 (including its single engine), but used cheek-mounted intakes to leave
the nose clear for a large radome for the 'Oriol-D' (Eagle) radar, and the T-5,
essentially a heavily modified Su-11 with a widened rear fuselage containing two
Tumansky R-11 engines.
These led to
the T-58, which combined the twin engines with a modified version of the T-49's
nose, but with side inlets further back, behind the cockpit. It was approved for
production on
The
improved Su-15T had an improved radar, the Taifun, and entered service in 1975,
rapidly replacing the Flagon-A.
Trumpeter’s Flagon-A is the initial Su-15. The “quick and dirty” way to tell a Flagon-A from the later Flagon-D is the wing form. The Flagon-D has a cranked wing leading edge, giving a longer span for better handling. The Flagon-A has a straight leading edge.
THE KIT |
The 4
sprues in the sturdy box were quite nicely molded.
There’s a clear 2-part canopy provided, but since I’m
using the Pavla add-ons, it won’t be used.
Other than overscale thickness, there’s no huge problem
with the clear parts.
Also, there are 2 landing light lenses on that clear
sprue, so don’t throw it away.
My first
thoughts were that since there were 3 “corrections” included in the box, this
was going to be one of those nightmare
Trumpeter
kits, like their F-105 that everyone complained about a while back.
Preparation of a large vat or tar and the procurement of
several bags of feathers was probably in order.
Not so, Igor, this kit is not a box shaker, but it’s
also not one that will have you throwing it at the wall.
All
parts were cleanly molded, with no “show stopper” ejector marks or mold part
lines.
Parts mated nicely, with no warp in the edges.
The locating pins on large parts actually helped keep
the parts aligned.
The panel lines were recessed, as is expected of a
post-20th Century model kit.
The many fasteners on some of the panels originally
looked to be overkill, but most of the photos I find show them very clearly.
I can’t really comment on the accuracy of the model beyond basic shape. There’s very little out there on the Flagon, and even less on the Flagon A. When the aircraft was originally built, everything was a state secret, and except for fuzzy photos taken at the annual Tushino air show, there wasn’t much out there which was unclassified. If Yefim Gordon could get around to doing a photo book on the Flagon, it will be a godsend.
CONSTRUCTION |
THE COCKPIT
The
Trumpeter kit does have an interesting method for handling the cockpit.
The upper deck of the fuselage is a separate part, with
a rectangular opening almost big enough to get the seat in.
I suspect this is to allow production of a Flanker-C
trainer version at a later date.
The Trumpeter cockpit is a single-piece tub, but the
nose gear well is 4 parts.
I assembled the gear well
and glued it
into one of the fuselage halves, then tackled the Pavla cockpit.
The
Pavla interior, particularly the seat and top deck are much better looking than
the Trumpeter offering, with Pavla providing details which Trumpeter omits, like
seat belts and consoles.
I did
some basic detail painting in the cockpit and the seat.
The Pavla instructions were very helpful here.
The Pavla instrument panel fit the fuselage part very
well, and looked good.
With the small opening and the seat in there, it’s hard
to see, though.
With that small opening, it’s necessary to complete the cockpit
and fit it into
the fuselage before adding the top deck.
I hit my first fit problem here.
As I was doing the test fit, the cockpit was just a bit
too tall to fit between the nose gear well and the fuselage deck.
I had to sand the bottom of the cockpit part until it
was translucent to get that top deck to fit.
I then
assembled the fuselage and interior, and prepared to put that top deck on.
Not all of these may have this problem, but mine was
about 1 mm short.
The Trumpeter part was OK, but lacking in detail.
Filler putty to the rescue.
THE TAIL
Now that
the fuselage was assembled, it was time to add that nice resin tail.
It fit the Trumpeter fuselage with no problem.
Because of the size of this part, it was necessary to
fill in a little at the bottom, but that would be true of the original kit part.
The “correction” is the addition of what appears to be a
tail warning receiver at the top of the fin, at the rear.
Some of the museum photos I find don’t have this
addition, but then possibly someone removed a secret part before turning it over
to public display?
I’d trust Pavla on this one, as they’re a lot closer to
any Su-15 than I am.
THE NOSE
Then it was
time to put on the Pavla
corrected nose.
The difference between the kit nose and the resin replacement are
pretty evident, as the original nose is an almost perfect cone, while the resin
has a subtle but noticeable ogive curve.
The curved nose was a change which was made to
Flagon-A’s when it was discovered that the straight nose interfered with the
radar.
As such, the Trumpeter nose might be used for an early Flagon-A.
Both noses fit OK on the front of the fuselage, but the
Pavla nose isn’t recessed like the Trumpeter version.
I suspect this has to do with the difficulty of getting
resin to consistently flow into a small area like that.
Another round of putty and sanding made this part OK.
THE REST
OF THE BUILD
There
was a fit issue on the wings.
The 2-piece wings are divided upper and lower, and have
the control surfaces molded only into the lower.
This provides a sharp trailing edge.
The upper wing sections were just a little too long
front-to-rear, and some
work with a
sanding stick was necessary to get a good fit here.
The
intakes and splitter plates fit fairly cleanly.
I had to use a little putty where the intakes met the
fuselage.
The exhausts are made up of 3 pieces.
There must be some engineering reason for this.
There are also 10 air scoops which are glued to the rear
of the fuselage in various spots.
The landing gear is fairly simple, with the 2 main gear
having a door which attaches to the leg.
The nose gear is another recognition feature.
All Flagon-A’s had a single nose wheel.
Later models had a double wheel setup, to better support
the weight of the radar unit in the nose.
CANOPY
The Pavla
cockpit set also includes two vac canopies, one having a periscope on top at the
center.
I found that the seat was too tall.
I had to remove that really nice resin seat, which was a
tight fit through that small cockpit opening, and then to sand off about 1 mm at
the bottom before the canopy could be installed.
I’m really glad I used craft glue instead of CA to put
that seat in.
The
canopy fit pretty well.
I had to use some white glue around the bottom because
my skills for cutting a canopy to fit a round fuselage top are somewhat
deficient.
I am not sure that the Flagon-A carried 4 missiles, but the kit has those nice AA-8 “Aphid” missiles, so I put them on, rather than screw around with trying to fill those large slots on the bottom of the wing on an already painted aircraft.
COLORS & MARKINGS |
Painting
was fairly simple.
The Flagon-A was built with a chromate-like paint on all
of the aircraft parts, and the exterior was then sprayed with an aluminum
coating.
This gives an overall uniform look to all the panels, without the
variation seen in a natural
metal
aircraft.
I used Testors Model Master Metalizer Aluminum for the exterior,
and Model Master enamels for all other painted parts.
The interior was done in Soviet blue/green, as were the
landing gear and gear legs.
The nose was done in a dark gray (actually 34118 gunship
gray).
The exhaust area was done in Burnt Metal Metalizer.
I coated the entire aircraft with Future before and
after decal application.
I used
the kit decals.
The intake warnings went on OK, and all the Soviet stars came off
the backing cleanly and I managed to get them all on straight and untorn.
There are about a bazillion little warning and
informational markings on the Flagon, and Trumpeter provides more than enough.
Sometimes it was difficult to determine exactly where a
marking went, as the drawings are approximately 1/144, or maybe just a bit
smaller than that.
CONCLUSIONS |
I have
built the PM Su-15, several years ago (the top kit on the image below. Ed),
and the Trumpeter kit shows the advance of the state of the art of producing
plastic models.
Trumpeter has released a kit which is pretty much OK.
The plethora of scoops makes this a slightly more
challenging project, but the basic parts, fuselage, wings, nose, engines,
stabilizers, and landing gear all fit pretty well.
The interesting thing about this build is that I had more trouble with the resin corrections than I did with the basic kit. I would still recommend the Pavla corrections to any modeler with the slightest hint of AMS, as the corrections are pretty much worth the extra work.
(A good reference would be Red Star #15: Su-9/11/15 by Yefim Gordon if you can locate it. Ed)
March 2009
Copyright ModelingMadness.com
Thanks to your editor via GreatModels for the review kit and Pavla Models for the resin bits.
If you would like your product reviewed fairly and quickly, please contact me or see other details in the Note to Contributors.