Osprey's French Soldier vs German Soldier - 1916

Author:

David Campbell

Publisher/Distributor

Osprey Publishing

Price

$22.00 MSRP

Reviewer:

Scott Van Aken

Notes: 80 pages, Combat #47
ISBN: 978-1-4728-3817-9

Osprey seems to have hit on a type of book that has become fairly popular. These books pit either soldiers or equipment against each other and allow us to see how they perform against each other. For the equipment it is the Duel series and for people it is this Combat series. #47 in the series pits the French Army against the German Army at Verdun.

By late 1915, trench warfare had become the norm. This sort of warfare produced minimal gains (if any) and required maximum effort for the attacker. Things were not roses for the defenders as these attacks were generally preceded by fairly intensive artillery. This resulted in not only destruction of defenses, but also the death and injury of a goodly number of defenders.

Then the attackers had to face a moonscape through which any sort of quick advancement was nigh impossible. It also put them fairly much out in the open for any counter artillery and the machine guns of the defenders. It was not uncommon for a unit to have 50% casualties during the attack phase.

In the time period of this book, the concentration was the fortress city of Verdun. This had the advantage for the Germans of being quite close to a railhead so that getting supplies was not a major issue and the attacking force could really build up prior to the actual attack. On the French side, the guns and most of the troops occupying the surrounding forts had been pulled away for use at other sectors. Once the German build up had been noticed, it was too late to do much about the gun situation and while some troops were brought in for reinforcements, building up the defenses was unable to reach completion. The result is that the Germans made some inroads, but not as expected in what turned into a very prolonged campaign.

As is the standard for this series, we are provided a fairly good look at the historical background, as well as the leaders and troops of both sides. This includes the training and the equipage of these troops. A look at the tactical and strategic situation of the sector is also provided. Then we are provided with three different battles during the campaign. In this case Bois du Caures, the initial assault of late February 1916. We then move to Mort Homme in April of 1916. Finally on to Fort Vaux in June of 1916. Each of these battles shows how well tactics worked and what was learned from the previous experiences. Then we are provided with an overall analysis.

In all, it makes for a super read of what in my mind was some of the most horrific fighting of that conflict. A book from which I learned and lot and one that I am sure you will like as well.

March 2020

For more on the complete line of Osprey books and to order this one, visit www.ospreypublishing.com .

If you would like your product reviewed fairly and quickly, please contact the editor or see other details in the Note to Contributors.