Flashback 1/48 Etrich Taube
KIT # |
8921 |
PRICE: |
$29.95 |
DECALS: |
See Review |
REVIEWER: |
|
NOTES: |
Short run multimedia kit |
HISTORY |
Ok, first a confession. This is the first kit I seriously approached that I
built without having a Datafile for the airplane. In fact, I am not sure a
Datafile exists for it since I didn’t look. Now that is one arrogant attitude!
But without a datafile it is not difficult to obtain information on this
aircraft.
First off, these airplanes
were anything but standardized in their construction. Being built well before
the war started in 1914 and up through the earliest days of the conflict, there
appears to have been many liberties taken in their construction. When the war
started the Taube was available and flying. It quickly became an experimental
platform for aerial reconnaissance. The saving grace of the airplane was that it
was simple and it flew. It is basically a very slow wing-warp-controlled
underpowererd kite. It was used successfully for reconnaissance work during the
intial German offensive into France in August 1914. It also served as the eyes
of Hindenburg’s army when he crushed the Russians at Tannenberg. The aircraft
had no permanent installation points for weapons. A 1914 era machine gun was
just too heavy for it to carry, so the two man crew resorted to simple
expedients. Rifles, pistols, hand grenades, even bricks - great to drop on other
airplanes!! Even with its modest degree of success, the Taube was obsolete at
the start of WW1. It was quickly replaced and by the end of 1914 was essentially
out of service.
THE KIT |
The Flashback kit represents a pre-war 1913 era Taube. It
consists of a few very simple plastic parts and photoetch for some detail.
Decals are for a prewar aircraft. Basically, there isn’t much to it until you
get to the rigging. This kit would be very difficult to build up and then rig as
one of the last steps; instead, it is more like build, rig, build, rig, etc.
The part quality is very
good. It has very little flash and good fit. The plastic goes together great; I
used only a little putty for seam filling. Instructions are the usual Eduard
drawings and very easy to follow. I don’t recommend that you follow their
sequence exactly though. I found that out the hard way.
Ed Maloney of the Planes of Fame Air Museum wanted a wartime Taube, so mine is
not exactly “out of the box”. What I did for documentation on wartime Taubes
was to search the internet. To obtain a wartime bird, I had to add some
additional features such as upgraded radiators, national insignia, upgraded
rigging, and armament. What I built was a hybrid of the Etrich Taube and the
wartime Taube. For a wartime Taube, I used photos of the Taube replica on
display at the Champlin Fighter Museum in Arizona that I obtained from my
internet search.
CONSTRUCTION |
I started out as I usually do, building the cockpits. This is
right out of the box, with only the addition of instrument panel bezels I added
using Tom’ Modelworks photo-etch, and construction was straightforward. The
small 6
cylinder in-line engine goes together easily and fits nicely in the engine
compartment. Don’t install the engine exhausts at this time since they will
only break off. This happened to me as I went on....duh (you’ll see why
shortly).
The fuselage halves mate very well with very little seam. The large wings attach
with slot/tab type fittings. So now I had this kit going together very well. So
what’s the problem?
PAINT & DECALS |
Painting - Obtaining that "fragile" look:
Before you start to paint this kit you have to understand that this is an
airplane with a very delicate structure, so delicate that on the real thing you
could see opaque lighting through the wing fabric. I really did not know how to
approach a method of recreating this on a plastic model. In fact, I was stumped.
So I stopped for a bit. As luck would have it I had a chance to be on the east
coast and stop by the Old Rheinbeck Aerodrome in upstate New York. On that visit
I saw my first real, flying examples of pre-WW1 airplanes built with similar
construction techniques.
The first thing that struck
me was the whitish look of the fabric coverings and the brownish look to the
ribs showing under the tight fabric. The other aspect that I noticed was the
staining on the fabric. Oil, dirt, fuel, wear, you name it, it had it. And these
airplanes were well maintained at old Rheinbeck!. Just think what a front line
Taube would look like after only a few hours of flying!
I primed my assembly using ModelMaster primer, fixed any remaining seams, then
gave the aircraft a coat of Future. I painted the forward portion of the
fuselage that was metal with SnJ aluminum metalizer. When dry I gave this a
buffing with SnJ powder to get a bright metal finish like it may be out of the
factory. I then “weathered” the bright metal with subtle swirls of Tamiya
“Smoke”. After masking off the cockpit, engine, and metalized portions of
the fuselage I was ready to try for that “fragile” effect.
First, I painted the fuselage with Gunze-Sanyo “Sail color ” acrylic and
covered that with a coat of Future. The next thing was to create the ribs and
fuselage skeleton, so as to obtain that “sticking out” look of the
structure. I used 1/64”drafting tape I found at my local art supply store and
covered all rib and structural points. This significantly raised the profile of
the underlying structure. I should have used dark brown tape but all I could
obtain was dark green. In any event, the idea was to get the ribs to shadow
through the fabric. I coated the tape ends with CA to avoid them curling up and
then I coated the fuselage with Future once again to seal the tape.
Since the fabric look I wanted was whitish and stained I needed a slightly off
white color. I mixed about 5 parts Tamiya flat white to 1 part of Gunze-Sanyo
"Sail Color" until I got a dirty white color. I airbrushed this onto
the fuselage very lightly, just enough to overcoat the underlying "Sail
Color" and slightly cover the much darker ribs. I then painted the sail
color over the dirty white and vice versa for several coats. Each subsequent
coat got a bit more sparse and a bit less consistent in overall coverage. The
result was some parts being dirty white, some a bit more brown, some more brown
still. I went for a random “patchy” effect. I think it took eight coats of
each in all to get to the final look.
I now needed to get the ribs
to stand out a bit more brownish. For this I used some reddish brown pastel
chalk applied with a microbrush which I just ran lightly over the tape. I had
never used pastels before so I just winged it. Nothing uniform, just enough.
After the pastel was applied, I coated the entire aircraft with Future and then
added another very light coat of dirty white. Then I Futured it again. The
result was close to what I had hoped: a dirty, splotchy fragile, rib-showing
"stringbag" effect. It looked ugly. I wasn’t sure this thing would
turn out in the end, but I kept on going.
Decals:
Time to decal. Americal Gryphon has a set of decals for early-war Taubes. One on
each wing surface, top and bottom. No decals on the fuselage per Americal’s
data even though the Champlin replica has them on the tail surfaces. I used a
lot of setting solution to get the decals to snug down over my tapes. When done
I gave the aircraft a good coat of Future to protect the decals during the long
rigging process.
Rigging:
This airplane has a lot of rigging on it, a bit over 100 inches of wire by my
estimate. Once you examine the rigging plan in depth, you will quickly realize
that building all the plastic parts at once will get you in trouble. The
airplane is very fragile. Rigging is supported on the top and underside by king
posts that just stick out into space from the flying surfaces. To rig this thing
you will spend a lot of time with the airplane on its back to rig the bottom,
and the king posts on the top of the wing will break unless you take care.
I would recommend that once the wings are installed, you turn the airplane over
and completely build and rig the underside of the airplane before doing any
rigging or installing the king posts on the upper surfaces.
I have a little wooden stand
I used to hold the airplane in place while I rigged it. It is just a simple box
structure that supports the wings and the tail near their tips. With the
airplane belly up, I installed the rigging support structural parts on each wing
and the underside tail surface. I then proceeded to install the bracing wire for
these structures. I used .007” diameter stiff steel wire for this rigging
using .0075” teflon tubing for turnbuckles. Once the support bracing was
installed, I built up the landing gear. Take care here because the gear is
really just a collection of 5 individual pieces of plastic rod and it is very
easy to warp it out of alignment. This turned out to be a bit of a task but was
made easier by doing the assembly with CA and kicker.
Once the gear was installed, I completed installing the support rigging for the
landing gear. I tossed out the PE underskid and replaced it with a curved
toothpick coated with CA glue to fix its shape. I did the underside tail rigging
last since it is very delicate. That was done using .004” stiff steel wire.
The rigging “fan out” blocks were built using a Waldron micro punch set.
All of my rigging is attached using white glue. My teflon tube technique
actually allows me to have a bit less than 2/10” play on each wire because I
can slide my teflon tubes on or off the wire to obtain a perfect fit. That saved
my sanity and I was able to rig this beast much more quickly than if I had to
“custom” fit each wire.
Another point I learned is not to attach any wiring exposed on the side of the
aircraft, like between side support posts and the tail structures until the very
last. I kept breaking these off as I moved the model during the build and
bumping it into paint bottles, lamps, etc.
From my experience, once the lower surfaces are rigged, just turn the model
over, install the king posts, and rig the upper surfaces. Install the engine
exhaust pipes before adding the rigging from the central support post forward
over the engine. Be sure the side rigging is last.
Finishing Up:
Once the rigging was finished I just had some simple paint touch ups remaining.
I “armed” my airplane with a scale WW1 Mauser rifle that I put into the
observer’s cockpit by propping it up against the seat. Now I really had a
warplane. I put a light coat of semi gloss “sheen” typical of WW1 fabric
covered airplanes onto the entire model. I made this by mixing a 30% solution of
Tamiya flat base to Future.
CONCLUSIONS |
I built a monoplane !! For me, that is a big deal having built
exactly one, count em’, one First World War monoplane airplane and I never
build anything from an era later than 1918. I have to face it, I’m a
multi-wing fanatic. So when a friend of mine asked me to build this kit for his
display of WW1 models my first thought was yes, it’s WW1!! Upon further
reflection I thought,,,oh God….boring.
I am very happy to report that the Taube was anything but boring, in fact my
experiences in building this kit went from pure joy, determined optimism, fist
clenching frustration, near tears, “throw it away and start again” anguish,
to relief and pride in having finished a pretty nice looking model of a very
“noticeable” airplane. These emotions were experienced in no particular
order and more than once during the build!
All I ever build are WW1
kits and this was the most difficult model I had ever built, but as with most
endeavors, if it doesn’t kill you it will make you stronger. I experimented
with techniques I never would have tried if I had stayed with a safe subject. I
learned a lot and I like the way the finished airplane looks. More than a
building project this was a “thinking” project. It is not straightforward.
Now that it is finished I have to admit a certain pride in having completed a
kit that I understand even very experienced model builders shy away from.
This is not a kit for your average builder. If you haven’t tackled a model
with more than average rigging then I would keep this one in the kit closet
until you get a bit more experience. The rigging is really the killer, not only
because it is intricate, but also that you have to “go it” alone for the
installation sequence and it can get frustrating when lovingly installed wires
fall off again and again. I can’t remember the number of times I had to walk
out of the room and just get away from it. I’m very happy to have had the
opportunity to build it for Planes of Fame because I don’t think I would have
started it for myself.
I probably spend at least 100 hours on this project and not all of it was
progress. But no need to shy away from this beauty - when it is finally finished
you will have one “looker” of a model; it will tax your abilities and you
will most likely come away the better model builder for it. You will never
be afraid of rigging a “stringbag” again.
A quick note: this model is the 20th that Candice Uhlir has built in her three year modeling career. Some people are just very talented.
Copyright ModelingMadness.com
If you would like your product reviewed fairly and fairly quickly, pleasecontact the editor or see other details in the Note to Contributors.
Back to Reviews Page 2017