Hawk 1/72 F4U Corsair
KIT # |
623 (et al) |
PRICE: |
Currently $6.99 |
DECALS: |
VF-84 |
REVIEW: |
Steve Mesner |
NOTES: |
Mini-review` |
THE KIT |
Ever see a kit that’s a real heartbreaker because about 75% of it is beautiful,
but the other
25% really bites? This is one of those kits.
The Testor F4U-1 is, of course, a reissue of the old Hawk kit, which dates back
to the
1950s. It’s been available in various boxes through the years. In one of the
more
interesting issues, Hawk tried to pass it off as an AU-1 with decals and
markings
instructions for a Gull Gray/White scheme! Another cool Hawk boxing had it in a
two-kit
“Marine Attack Set” (or some such name) with their F4D Skyray. The current
Testor
boxing has decals for VF-84, and about two years ago I bought one (at a
warehouse
liquidator place) in another two-kit boxing with the old Hawk SBD Dauntless--two
kits,
decent decals, and even some acrylic paint for something like $5.50. Never
thought I’d say
this, but at today’s prices, that’s not a bad deal. The single kit of the Testor
Corsair is
currently priced at a breathtaking $6.99 at a local arts-n-crafts store. (I
remember when it
was 50 cents!)
Whatever the age, brand, or boxing, the kit is the same. The fuselage from the
cowling
back, and the wings, are nicely done, with detailing in very fine engraved
lines--quite an
accomplishment for the 1950s! The shape looks good and the fit isn’t bad. The
tricky Corsair dihedral is correctly molded right into the sturdy two-piece wing, so
there’s not
much to screw up there.
From there on, however, it’s all downhill. The separate cowling piece has flaps
represented all around it, and is shallowly engraved on its front face with some
scratching
that I suppose is intended to represent a radial engine. The propeller is
incorrectly shaped,
being reverse-tapered. The entire landing gear setup, including the doors, is
very crudely
represented, and the wheels are featureless. The oil coolers in the wing root
leading edges
are represented only by flat spots in the wings.
There is no cockpit whatsoever--the “pit” is simply covered over in plastic. The
F4U-1A
type canopy’s framing is molded into the fuselage halves. The glass snaps down
into place
onto the assembled fuselage. It’s nicely shaped and fits well, though.
For “goodies,” the kit comes with the large centerline belly tank, four
too-short,
inaccurately-mounted 5” HVARs for under the wings, and a pair of small bombs
that are
supposed to go on a pair of outer-wing pylons unlike anything I’ve ever seen on
any real
Corsair. All garbage.
Seeing how nice the basic airframe is--and how bad all the peripheral parts
are--almost
makes you want to cry. The basic shape is there, and assembly is easy enough
that this
would make a great first kit for a kid. It goes almost without saying that it’s
a terrific "nostalgia” build if you had one back during the Kennedy administration, but if
you’re old
enough to get nostalgic over this thing, you’re probably going to be very
unsatisfied with
the results you get straight out of the box.
IDEAS |
With much better kits available at reasonable prices, this one isn’t worth time
or money
trying to bring up it to standards for a common, garden-variety F4U-1. So what
can you
do with this relic that can make use of the good parts? Here are some ideas:
1. If you just happen to have the cowling, engine, prop, landing gear, etc., of
almost any
other 1/72 Corsair laying around unused, bolt ‘em on. By bashing parts from the
Testor/Hawk and either an Airfix or Revell Corsair, you might be able to come up
with
one good model that’s better than either kit could make on its own.
2. The Italeri F4U-4B kit has come in for criticism for shape and accuracy
problems. Bash
the whole front fuselage (and cowling, engine, prop) of that kit from the wing
spar line
forward onto the Testor/Hawk, use the Testor/Hawk wings, and add the Italeri oil
coolers, landing gear, etc. The Italeri cockpit isn’t right for an F4U-1A, but
go ahead and
cheat and use it. Now you’ve got a nifty early F4U-4 with accurate fuselage
shape, round
windscreen, and fabric-covered 6x.50-cal wings (the Italeri kit has the
metal-covered ones,
which are wrong for a -4). Add a Squadron vac canopy and a True Details F4U-1
cockpit
and you’d have a real show-winner! (Save the Italeri wings for a future
folded-wing
Corsair project, put remaining ordnance in the spares box, and dump everything
else left
over from both kits in the trash!)
3. Been wanting to do an R4360-powered F2G or Wasp Major conversion? The
Testor/Hawk kit’s nice airframe is a natural starting point, whether you’re
scratchbuilding
or using a commercially available conversion (I don’t know of any offhand, but
I’m sure
there’s been at least one made somewhere sometime by somebody). You still need a
cockpit, and better landing gear and wheels, but watch the jaws drop at the
local club
when you tell ‘em the basis of your sharp F2G is the ancient Hawk kit!
4. Or, if you’re lazy, do what I did: Smack it together gear-up and put it on a
desktop
stand. The model shown here is actually a rebuild project I did from an old
original Hawk
kit that had lost its landing gear somewhere down through the years. Rather than
try to fit
the kit gear doors (some of which might have even been missing; I don’t
remember) into
the up position, I cheated and simply covered the entire gear wells with common
Scotch
tape, then trimmed the tape to just outside the gear well borders. After a
general cleanup
of the airframe with files, sandpaper, and some putty where needed, the whole
mess got a
good squirt of Glossy Sea Blue, which seems to have done a nice job of sealing
the edges
of the Scotch tape (it hasn’t lifted nearly four years later!) The “cockpit,”
prop, and
“engine” got hand-brushed Flat black. After applying some generic SuperScale
starts-and-bars, I cut a slot in the bottom of the fuselage to fit a flying
stand from an old
Matchbox kit.
The finished rebuild looks great on my desk at work, and if someone knocks it
off--or
even steals it altogether--I haven’t lost much. I had fun reworking the thing,
and isn’t that
what the hobby is supposed to be about?
CONCLUSIONS |
If you want a nice -1 Corsair model in 1/72, give the Testor reissue of the Hawk
F4U-1 a
pass. For what you get, and considering what else is available, I’d consider
this kit to be
overpriced at $5, much less $6.99. Its problems are likely to be a stumbling
block to even the “nostalgia modeler.” Still, sometimes you need to buy a gift for a youngster
that costs,
oh, say, about $6.99. And if you happen to find one of these old crocks hiding
in a dark
forgotten corner of your modeling closet, there ARE ways to have a bit of fun
with it.
Model on!
If you would like your product reviewed fairly and fairly quickly, please contact the editor or see other details in the Note to Contributors.