Monogram 1/48 Typhoon Ib
KIT #: 5221
PRICE: $
DECALS: One option
REVIEWER: Pablo Calcaterra
NOTES:

Part III of III on Argentine-British 164 Sqn (RAF) – Firmes Volamos.  Falcon canopy Set #31, Eduard 49006 prepainted photo-eteched seat belts

HISTORY

Little was known about the involvement of Argentine volunteers in the RAF, RCAF and RN until Oscar Raimondi started his research work a few years ago along with Claudio Meunier who continued and enhanced this project after Raimondi’s death.

There were almost 1,000 Argentine volunteers that joined the flying forces during World War II. Most of them were descendants of British people living in Argentina (i.e. working in the Great Southern Railways) and thus their names are, no doubt about it, British. But there are many other volunteers that have Spanish names and yet joined the RAF, RCAF and RN. They flew in every theater of operations and flew practically all the planes available (from bombers to fighters to transport to trainers). Some of them remained in Europe after the war, but others went back to Argentina.

During WWII the British community in Argentina organized the 'Wings for Winston Foundation of Buenos Aires'. This Foundation gathered money with the aim of creating an all-Argentine fighter squadron (planes purchased with Argentine money and flown by Argentina born pilots). The dream finally came true on April 6th 1942 when 164 Sqn was formed.

For the 164 Spitfire period check Part I . For the 164 Hurricane period check Part II.

Typhoon phase for 164 Sqn:

This article has bits of information gathered here and there (see references) and it is a little bit sketchy. But it is probably the most complete one yet published about 164 Sqn during the last year and half of the war.

In January 1944 and being led by Sqn Ldr Humphrey Russell DFC (a Battle of Britain fighter pilot veteran) 164 Sqn started to receive their Typhoons with their Hurricanes soldiering on until February. The Squadron was based in Twinwood Farm, passing briefly thru Acklington. 164 were at Thorney Island, between Portsmouth and Chichester, from March 15th to April 11th 1944 and from 22 April to 17th June 1944.

First Typhoon missions against German targets were flown in March, radar sites being the most significant ones.

During one mission on May 28th against a radar site in the Fruges area Sqn Ldr Russell destroyed the target with his well-placed rockets but at the same time his Tiffie (FJ-L / JR515) was hit by the intense flak. Climbing to 4,000 ft he told his men he was going to bail out, left his plane and became a POW. Flt Sgt Fisher’s plane was hit in the cockpit but he was not injured.

Sqn Ldr Percival Beake then took over the Squadron first at Funtington, a satellite airfield just North of Thorney Island, then at Hurn (Bournemouth) from 21st June to 17th July 1944. During this period there were two Anglo-Argentines flying in 164 Sqn: F/S “Feddie” Greene and F/L Bertie Brownrigg. Other pilots in the squadron were F/L A. Todd, F/O P. West, F/S G. Fowell, F/S R Wilson, P/O Wilkirsch, F/O A. Roberts (from Australia), 136 Wing W/C Bryan (an ace with 5 kills and the DFC and bar), F/S McDonnell, King and White.

Another type of Argentine volunteers where the women that flew in Ferry Comand. One of them, Maureen Dunlop (born in Rio Negro) arrived in an Auster III with Brownrigg on June 3rd and then she flew away a Typhoon to undergo a major inspection. She accumulated more than 1,300 hours in Spits, Hurricanes, Typhoons, Tempests, Mosquitoes and Wellingtons!

In the month between May and June the squadron flew 139 sorties.

 D Day:

Based in Hurn during June and July 1944 164 Sqn became part of No.136 Wing; No.84 Group; Second Tactical Air Force; Allied Expeditionary Air Force.

June 6th 1944 was an especially busy day for 164 Sqn. Their first mission was flown at 11.20 am. F/O Roberts saw the Germans first and his rockets along with the ones fired by F/O Kelly destroyed some enemy vehicles. Some 5 kilometers further on Sqn Ldr Beake found a train and the locomotive was eliminated by the combination of Beake’s and F/S Black’s rockets. Shortly afterwards Kelly saw another car and Beake ordered him to make sure it was not friendly. After a pass over the vehicle Kelly shouted that he had been shot at from the car with machine guns. Wing commander Bryan commanded: “Kelly, wipe him out immediately!” Following the Kubelwagen on the road Kelly opened fire with the 20 mm cannons and the car cartwheeled. A third pass by Kelly confirmed that the target had been destroyed.

While the attention of pilots was centered on the ground targets two Fw-190 almost caught the squadron unaware. Luckily F/O Dean gave the warning. Turning to gain the tail of a Focke Wulf F/L Todd fired a burst that hit the drop tank of the German fighter. The flaming tank was released but it was already too late and yellow flames were licking the fuselage. While in a wide turn the German pilot opened the hood and jumped clear of this doomed plane that crashed in a farm.

At 17.30 ten planes took off and minutes later they were flying low in the Bayeaux area searching for more targets. A small group of German vehicles was crossing a metal bridge over a small river. Diving against them the 164 Sqn pilots made short work of their enemies. But the Germans could bite too and F/O Robert’s plane was hit, lost a wing and the out of control plane (MN466) hit the ground at 700 km/h killing the pilot.

After the exhausted pilots returned from their second mission, and saddened by the loss of their friend, Beake was called to the phone. Yet another mission was requested! So at 21.15 nine planes took off and patrolled the Lisiseux-Caen-Falaise area. An Advance Air Controller led them to another German convoy. Freddie Greene attacked first in almost darkness and again the Typhoons made short work of vehicles and soldiers. This time there were no losses…but after landing close to midnight Beake told them that the next mission was scheduled for 5.25 am!

Onwards:

The next significant even took place on June 8th when Winco Bryan (in MN415) led his section low over the ground searching for targets. After firing their rockets and destroying a locomotive he saw twelve 109s diving to the attack. His section was low but the covering section led by F/L A. Todd in FJ-Y caught the Messerschmitts by surprise. Todd and F/S Wilson got 300 yards behind a 109 and their guns shot down the fighter. Wing Commander Bryan damaged two more 109s.

Tragedy struck 164 two days later. While attacking yet another German column of vehicles, flak hit Bryan’s Typhoon and the pilot was killed when the plane exploded. It was a heavy price to be paid for 10 German vehicles destroyed. The Anglo-Argentine Brownrigg was posted to 183 Sqn on this day.

On June 20th a train station in Caen was attacked by 164 Sqn at dusk. The remaining Anglo-Argentine Freddie Greene was among the pilots that took part in this mission. One of the salvoes hit a train loaded with ammo and the following day a recco Mosquito brought back pictures that showed just a huge hole on the ground.

Sqn Ldr Beake tells us first-hand what happened on June 24th. The mission was flown from Hurn via Needs Oar Point, an ALG to the East of Lymington, between the Beaulieu River and the Solent.

 “My most memorable combat mission of the war was an attack we carried out on a German Army HQ in a chateau at St. Sauveur Endelin on 27th June 1944 (it actually was near Saint-Sauveur-Lendelin, North of Coutances in the Cherbourg peninsula – Anthony Knight). At the time I was OC 164 Squadron stationed at Hurn and living under canvas. We had been released at midday but, notwithstanding that, a signal was brought to me in the Mess tent where we were having lunch requiring four aircraft to be sent to Needs Oar Point to take part in an evening operation.” “I was disappointed and annoyed for, having released the squadron, I now had to countermand that for some. I summoned up my two Flight Commanders, told them the situation and said that I wanted two pilots from each flight ~ volunteers preferably but, if necessary, they would have to detail participants.” “Although only a section of four was required, I made it a practice to take a „spare‟ with me part way so that if anyone had to drop out with engine trouble, or for any other reason, in the early stages of the mission I had an airborne replacement I could call on. If I considered everything was going well I would waggle my wings and the „spare‟ would return to base.” “Having eaten I gathered the four nominated pilots together and went to dispersal where we donned our flying kits and took off for the 15 minute flight to Needs Oar Point. On the way there my airscrew developed an oil leak. On landing I was warmly greeted by members of 193 squadron with whom I had been a Flight Commander from its formation to three months previously. One pilot climbed up to me in the cockpit and, seeing the oil on the windscreen, said “I certainly wouldn’t take this kite if I were you, boss” (This was "Killy" Kilpatrick of 193 Squadron and Anthony Knight’s uncle). “We were eventually called in to the briefing where we were told what the target was and shown a map for its location. The general plan was for eight „Bombphoons‟ (Typhoon Bombers) in two sections of four to go in first at low level, I had to follow with my rocket firing section and the last sixteen would dive bomb from high level to finish off the attack. The low level bombs would be fitted with 11 second delay fuses. Coming from the briefing all of my thoughts were negative and for some reason my confidence was at an all-time low.” “I was still suffering annoyance at having been called on when already released, my aircraft had developed an oil leak and could be termed unserviceable, our target would undoubtedly be very heavily defended, I had neither the surprise element of the low level bombers to protect me nor the partial protection of height afforded to the dive bombers. In fact I was beginning to think this may well be my last “op‟. “We took off as planned and these thoughts were running through my mind as I watched the specks of oil gathering on my windscreen. How much oil was I losing and how much could I afford to lose ~ thinking of the 90 odd miles of water we had to cross before reaching France and of the fading daylight that would not leave a lot of time for rescue if I had to bail out. These thoughts nagged at me and I was sorely tempted to call in my „spare‟ and turn back to safety. But no! If I did that and any of my four failed to return I would find it very hard to live with myself so I waggled my wings and my „spare‟ broke away to return to base.” “We arrived in the target area at 9.30pm. The first section of four low level bombers was led by W/Co Baldwin and the second section in had to allow at least an 11 second gap before going in to avoid being blown up by the bombs of the first section. Similarly I had to allow a like interval after the second section had gone in before diving down and releasing my rockets. When the first bombs were dropped flak erupted from all around with tracer shells showing up starkly in the gathering dusk. By the time it was safe for me to lead my section down the flak was tremendous and, looking down, it seemed quite impossible for anyone to dive down into that inferno without getting hit ~ but we did and there were no casualties. The chateau and all that was within it was completely destroyed. We withdrew over the Cherbourg Peninsula and made our way across the Channel to our respective bases.” “So why was this so memorable to me? Firstly this was very satisfying to have taken part in such a hugely successful operation without sustaining any casualties. Secondly my confidence at the outset was at its lowest point ever so that the cards seemed heavily stacked against my survival and I really had to steel myself to stay with the formation in an aircraft leaking oil and not knowing how serious that might become. I guess there was a bit of self-satisfaction in that I had resisted the very strong urge to “chicken out” even though there was a justifiable reason for doing so.”

During another ground attack mission on July 6th F/S Fisher’s engine started to falter and it hit the Channel. F/S Fowell also was lost to flak but his body was never found. Fisher’s body was retrieved from the water by HMS Lightfoot.

In July 1944 the Squadron moved to France and was briefly based at B.8 Sommervieu and then at B.7 Martragny until September.

On August 6th Sqn Ldr Beake led an attack on a quarry. The day after he took a 48 hs leave and upon his return 164 Sqn (August 9th) attacked time and time again a dump that finally was destroyed on August 11th. This task being successfully carried out, the squadron started their offensive recco missions. On the 13th Wing commander Walter Dring summoned Beake and informed him that that had been his last op in the following words: “Beaky, you have just done your last op. You are not to fly again and that is an order, until returning to the UK. I am arranging for your relief as soon as possible”. Stunned and embarrassed of sending his squadron to action but not being able to fly with them he was finally replaced by the New Zealander Sqn Leader Ian Waddy.

Just 3 days after taking command of the Squadron, Ian Waddy was shot down and killed by flak.

F/L A. Napier, DFC was shot down and killed on August 14th.

On 18 August 164 Sqn took part in a four-squadron attack on German armour at Chambois, during the battle of the Falais pocket, helping to destroy a force of around 100 armoured vehicles.

On August 20th the famous Belgian ace Remmy “Buzzy” Van Lierde (DFC and bar) took over. He was a pilot in the Belgian Air Force during the 1940 campaign, was shot down on May 16th 1940 and manage to get to the UK after fleeing the Germans thru France and being interned in Spain. He had 35 (or 44) V1 to his credit and finished the war with 6 victories (7 according to other sources), 1 probable and 1 damaged.

Five days later tragedy again hit the squadron when F/O G Trafford and F/S R. White were shot down and killed.

“Buzzy” flew his first mission with 164 Sqn on August 30th. The following day his plane was hit by flak in the mainplane during a mission against yet another radar site but he made it back to base.

The squadron made the following moves during September: B.23 Morainville, B.35 Baromesnil, B.53 Merville.

Between September 6th and 22nd 164 Sqn attacked guns positions in the Le Havre, Boulogne, Calais, Niuport and Cap Gris Nez.

On September 23rd 164 Sqn was flying over Boulogne and when getting ready to attack, the Germans positions surrendered. The loudspeakers inviting them to do so plus the sight of the circling Typhoons was too much to bear.

The Army sent a congratulatory message to the Squadron when they destroyed an old fort West of Calais on the 26th

After the breakout moved forward through northern France and Belgium in support of the 21st Army Group. For the remaining months of the war, the squadron was engaged in reconnaissance sweeps, attacking enemy transport and tanks.

Between October and November 1944 164 Sqn was based at B.67 Ursel

On Saturday October 7, 1944, during Operation "Switchback" as the Canadian Army was attacking one of the last German pockets of resistance in Belgium, 164 Sqn gave direct support. The pilot of Typhoon MN-862 reported that his engine was giving him trouble (most likely he had been hit by flak). The plane crashed and exploded near Damme (Belgium) with F/S James Teather still inside. His body was found one month later by the Allies advancing in the area. Teather had taken part in the successful attacks in the Calais and Boulogne area and was responsible of the destruction of the fort that earned the Squadron the message from the Army on the 26th. A headstone was placed and the text was written was his widow. It reads:

“He lived and died for those he loved
And those he loved remember”

Sadly his son was born 20 days after Teather was killed. Late in the 90s Teather’s watch was recovered from the site by a Belgian and returned to his widow who visited the crash site for the occasion.

 The push forward of the Allies made more moves for 164 Sqn: From November till March saw them at B.77 Gilze-Rijen (with a small leave to Fairwood Common and a move to A.84 Chievres in January)

 On January 1st the Squadron had landed at Gilze-Rijen and was about to fly to Chievres to join the rest of the Wing when at 9 am they were attacked by approximately 16 German fighters (FW-190, Bf-109 and Me-262) during Operation Bondenplatte. One of 164 Sqn Typhoons was destroyed and another one was Cat B (damaged). The Germans lost two 109s and one 262 over the airfield, hit by the British AA gunners.

In January Van Lierde was replaced by Sqn Ldr P.L. Bateman Jones. On February 14th the Squadron lost P/O Ian Moore.

 After the lessons of Operation Market Garden it was decided to give a much closer support to the Army. Therefore a base with 2nd TAF planes was established and their task was to give flak suppression during Operation Varsity. The squadrons that were based at B.91 Klius (near Nijmegen) were 164, 183, 198, 609, 33, 222 and 274. The Argentine British Squadron was based there from March 21st till April 17th. They attacked gun positions in support of Varsity (east of Rhine) and artillery at Wesel on March 24th, military transports and guns emplacements.

 On April 1st Sqn Ldr Bateman Jones made a force landing after an armed recce. The following day a radar station was hit near Amsterdam. 164 Sqn then moved to first German base in April 1945 (B.103 Plantlunne and then B.116 Wunstorf).  

 More attacks followed on gun positions during the month. On the 9th Bateman Jones’ plane was hit by flak and was forced to land at B.88 (Hesch). The following day W/O D. McCulloch was hit by Allied flak and his plane exploded in the air killing the pilot. The squadron attacked vehicles, barges and strong points.  According to the records of 164 Sqn the attacks on Appeldorn had been so successful that the Allies took the place without losing single man.

 On April 25th the Squadron lost two planes that hit by flak forced landed near Neumuster (F/L Jones and F/O Wilson). The following day F/O Lawston had to bail out from his plane when it was hit by flak at Wilhelmshaven.

One of the most important characters of the squadron was Bill Bags from Canada. He flew more than 100 sorties with 164 Sqn. When he joined the Squadron he was surprised that it was an Argentine-British one as he was under the impression that the Argentines were Nazi sympathizers. But he found a band of brothers that came from all over the world: Belgian, Frenchmen, Poles, South Africans, Rhodesians, and an American. When he was rested he was sent as forward air controller in a tank of the 4th Canadian Armoured Brigade. From his tank he would lead his fellow airmen to attack targets that were, in some cases, less than 100 yards away from his position. He later commented that this assignment was scarier than flying his Typhoon. Bill Bags DFC passed away on September 10, 2012 ago in Toronto, ON.

When the war in Europe ended 164 Sqn was sent back to the UK where it received No.453 Squadron's Spitfires, before being renumbered as No.63 Squadron on 31 August 1946.

THE KIT

This is the 1969 issued kit molded in dark green plastic. Profile of the plane is very accurate (though the tail is not as rounded as it should be), raised (and incorrect) panel lines, spartan cockpit, only one option of awful decals (you can see the pixels/dots in the dark colours).

CONSTRUCTION

This one of the first kits I painted with an airbrush back in Argentina in the 90s. It came to Canada along with other model planes when we moved here and suffered at the hands of the Customs Agents who opened the boxes and messed with the kits. As a consequence this Typhoon lost one cannon, the canopy. When I checked the kit the undersides (especially) had yellowed because I used to use the Humbrol clear varnish.

I decided to re construct the plane and give it a second life, this time as one of the planes of 164 Sqn.

First I left the kit in bleach for several days but it looks like the layers of paint and varnish were very thick as I was barely able to remove paint even using an old tooth brush (in other kits the Humbrol paints would just fall off like sand). So I decided to go with a more drastic approach: oven cleaner. I first unglued the landing lights and wing tip lights as the product would make them dull.

It took an entire can of cleaner to remove the paint. Not so much because of the paint itself but because the decals now were protecting the paint underneath and the oven cleaner did not even scratched them!

As this plane is based on the only surviving one when it was based in the US in the 60s and incorrectly (for most of the planes) it has the plate around the exhaust stacks, I sanded it out.

This accomplished I re-scribed all the panel lines using the scale planes in the Valiant book Hawker Typhoon by Richard A. Franks. This was the first time I tackled this approach and I got some input by the more than skillful Tony Bell. I made copies of the scale planes in 1/48 and proceeded to cut out each panel carefully. This panel was put in place using masking tape and Dymo tape bordered it. The pieced of paper was lifted out and then the panel line marked with an Xcto knife (10). This process took several days.

There were some areas that I had properly fixed in the past using putty, but others that I had overlooked were taken care of this time (i.e. ejection marks under the tail planes). In other cases my panel lines had gone a little bit too long and had to be covered with putty as well.

One blare omission in the original kit is the lack cylindrical tanks inside the wheel wells. Using unused tropical filters from some Hobbycrafts Bf109s that were cut in length I was able to replicate these missing parts.

Another thing that is missing is the very subtle humps on the inward cannons. Again using the scale plans I cut out a very thin strip of Evergreen, glued it, sanded the edges to merge them with the surface of the wing and added some putty here and there to improve the union. The missing cannon came from a Hasegawa Typhoon kit (as I am planning on converting the car door kit into an early MK1a).

The planes flown by 164 Sqn were three propelled and the kit has four. So I did some major surgery to the hub by cutting out the 4 bases, aligning 3 of them using the scale plans, and covering the resulting gaps with pieces of plastic that were left. Some putty and sanding took care of the imperfections and I ended up with a 3 blade propeller.

The tip of the tail was sanded to round it and achieve the correct profile. The seat (quite inaccurate I read it is) fell off from the cockpit. The plane was ready for painting after washing it with water and soap.

COLORS & MARKINGS

I sprayed the spinner and the fuselage band with Modelmaster RAF sky. The leading edge of the wings and propeller tips received a very nice coat of yellow (MM Acryl 4721). I then masked the leading edge in a way that exposed the yellow. I then covered the yellow edge with masking tape and removed the first band of masking tape. This allowed me to have the correct profile for the yellow bands and at the same time, having painted it over the sky color, saved me the headache of giving the edges layer after layer of yellow to try to cover the cammo colours. It is a backwards process that takes more time (twice masking) but delivers better results.

I used Model Master Acryl 4759 for the inferior surfaces and the entire kit to check for imperfections during my re-scribing process. Once the undersides and the band were masked with Tamiya tape and paper I airbrushed the darker gray for the fuselage and wings using Model Master Acryl 4746. To correctly describe the cammo I made copies of the profiles in the Valiant book color plans, cut them and attached them using masking tape. Then worms of Blue tac added to the edge of the paper masks helped to achieve a soft demarcation. Once this was done a coat of Model Master Acryl RAF Dark Green finished the cammo.

Rockets and rails were also painted in light gray, along with the landing gear doors. The pad inside the landing gear doors received a coat of aluminum.

My usual technique of sanding black pastel and applying it to some areas with a brush delivered some wear and depth (moveable surfaces). A silver pen created an effect of chipped paint especially around fasteners, walking area on wings and edge of panels.

Stains behind the exhausts were created using a mix of rust and black-sanded pastels and a brush (I believe I overdid these). These were also used to get the undersides a little bit dirty.

Landing lights were given a coat of Future and the demarcation line was painted half in yellow and half in underside gray.

The intake was painted in diluted black that pooled only on the recesses thus making the grid stand out. The interior face of the intake was painted following the camouflage in that area.

The main landing gear was glued in place as support for the plane during the process of applying Future.

After the layers of Future were applied the plane was ready for the decals.

All stencils were copied from the Hasegawa kit in clear decals and applied. Main decals were Super Scale 48-541 decals for roundels and tail bands, Aeromaster 48-237 for the Sky letters. They all went on with no problem and acted properly to the Set/Sol combination.

A coat of semi-gloss Model Master Acryl varnish protects the decals.

FINAL CONSTRUCTION

I worked the undersides outwards: added small landing gear doors, rockets, landing lights and wingtip lights. From the spares box I retrieved a Venturi that I glued under the wing after painting it in grey and rust.

I removed the masking tape from the vacuum formed canopy. The prepainted seat belts were added to the seat and this one was carefully wriggled inside the cockpit sides. The light behind the seat received a couple of drops of chrome silver.

The two pouches than contain the tools for the landing gear were made of brown painted masking tape and stuck to the back walls of the wheel wells.

The gun sight was cut out from a thin sheet of clear film. The reflective light was made with a drop of chrome silver and the gun sight was glued in place.

The canopy was attached carefully using Testors glue after scratching its contour on the fuselage paint.

I had set aside the unused decals from the SMER SM79 to use some large black bands this sheet has…only to put them away in one day of confusion pondering why had I left the decals aside…With the plane finished…I realized that I had forgotten to add the anti-slipping black bands on the wing roots…and those black SMER decals were going to be used for the anti-slipping bands! So out came the decals but they are quite old and they fell apart easily and attached themselves to the kit firmly. So the fact that they cracked here and there was useful as it gave the bands a worn out look. With this accomplished my Typhoon was finished.

CONCLUSIONS

It has been clearly superseded by the Hasegawa offering in terms of details but still makes a nice Tyffie. This has been the last of the 3-part series about the little known164 Sqn.

Thanks to:

Sqn. Ldr. Percival Beake DFC for his kind permission to use his text.

Anthony Knight (Secretary, TECT = Typhoon Entente Cordiale Trust) for all his help to get in touch with Mr. Beake, his support and kindness to use text from the TECT (Typhoon Entente Cordiale Trust). Highly recommended if you are a fan of the old or new Typhoon! You can visit them at www.tect.org.uk

REFERENCES

·        TECT- Newsletter 1 Spring 2011

·        Alas de Trueno (Claudio Meunier)

·        The Hawker Typhoon by Richard A. Franks (Valiant)

·        BBC’s WWII People’s war: A Message from 1944 RAF Typhoon Pilot Brian Teather

·        http://www.thememoryproject.com/stories/654:bill-mitchell-baggs/

·        Royal Air Force website: History RAF Formations – 164 Sqn

·        Regimental-Art.com (Percival Beake)

·        The Hawker Tempest Page (www.hawkertempest.se)

·        Nijmegen Market-Garden Veterans’ website http://home.kpn.nl/been0319/stories6.html

Pablo Calcaterra

November 2012

Thanks to    for the preview kit. You can find this kit at your favorite hobby shop or on-line retailer.

If you would like your product reviewed fairly and fairly quickly, please contact the editor or see other details in the Note to Contributors.

Back to the Main Page

Back to the Review Index Page