Art Model 1/72 Polikarpov I-185
|KIT #:||AM 7206|
|PRICE:||$14.45 from www.scale-model-kits.com|
|REVIEWER:||Scott Van Aken|
The I-185, designed in early 1940, was based on the I-180, which was itself a development of the I-16, but was virtually a new design. The monocoque fuselage was similarly built of 'shpon', molded birch plywood, and also had an integral tailfin, but it was considerably longer than that of the I-180. The two-spar, all-metal wing was smaller and thinner than the I-180's wing, nearly as thin as that of the Supermarine Spitfire's wing at 13% at the root and tapered to 8% at the wing tip. The wing had a NACA-230 profile and was skinned in duralumin. Pneumatically powered split flaps and leading edge slats were fitted. The outer wing panels had 3° of dihedral. The fabric-covered control surfaces were framed in duralumin. The protected 540-litre (119 imp gal; 143 US gal) fuel tanks were mounted between the wing center section spars. The I-185 used a conventional undercarriage with a retractable tail wheel. The unproven 1,492 kW (2,000 hp) 18-cylinder, two-row Tumansky M-90 radial engine was carried on welded steel tubes. It was fitted with a ducted spinner to improve cooling with the air expelled through gills as in the I-180 to provide additional thrust. The synchronized armament was mounted in the fuselage, two 7.62 mm (0.300 in) ShKAS machine guns and two 12.7 mm (0.50 in) Berezin UBS machine guns. A 500-kilogram (1,100 lb) bomb could be carried under overload conditions. The first prototype was completed in May 1940, but the only available example of the M-90 did not provide enough power for take-off. The prototype was modified to use another experimental engine, the 895-kilowatt (1,200 hp) Shvetsov M-81 radial, but this was not nearly powerful enough for flight tests. The I-185 (M-81) finally took to the air on January 11, 1941, but it was decided not to waste further development and await a more powerful engine which was fortunate as the M-81 was cancelled in May 1941.
A second prototype was completed at the end of 1940 with a 14-cylinder, 1,268 kW (1,700 hp) Shvetsov M-82A radial engine. The forward fuselage had to be redesigned to accommodate the slimmer engine and the armament was revised to three synchronized 20 mm (0.79 in) ShVAK cannon. The drawings for this engine installation was passed to Lavochkin and Yakovlev where they proved very useful in designing their own fighters using the M-82 engine, notably the Lavochkin La-5. A third prototype was also built that used the larger and heavier Shvetsov M-71 radial engine of 1,492 kW (2,000 hp). The flight tests of both of the latter versions were interrupted by the German invasion in June 1941 and all three prototypes, plus the Polikarpov design bureau, were evacuated to Novosibirsk.
Flight testing resumed in early 1942 and the M-71-powered versions, which now included the re-engined first prototype, proved to be faster than the Messerschmitt Bf 109F by 47 km/h (29 mph) at sea level and 20 km/h (12 mph) at 6,000 metres (19,685 ft) with a top speed of 630 km/h (390 mph) at that altitude. It was recommended for immediate production, even before it began combat trials in November 1942. All three aircraft were assigned to the 728th Fighter Aviation Regiment of the 3rd Air Army of the Kalinin Front and were tightly controlled to prevent the loss of the prototypes. For example, all sorties had to be flown over Soviet-controlled territory and required the express permission of the 3rd Air Army staff to fly. Pilots' reports were quite enthusiastic; the 728th's commander, Captain Vasilyaka wrote: "The I-185 outclasses both Soviet and foreign aircraft in level speed. It performs aerobatic maneuvers easily, rapidly and vigorously. The I-185 is the best current fighter from the point of control simplicity, speed, maneuverability (especially in climb), armament and survivability."
Based on the glowing report by the NII VVS (Naoochno-Issledovatel'skiy Institoot Voyenno-Vozdooshnykh Seel—Air Force Scientific Test Institute) in early 1942 preparations began to put the I-185 (M-71) into production. A 'production standard setter (etalon)' aircraft was built in April 1942 with a redesigned engine cowling. Its gross weight increased by 144 kg (320 lb) over the earlier prototypes, but the reduction in drag from the new cowling was significant and the top speed increased to 650 km/h (400 mph) at 5000 meters. It underwent manufacturer's tests between June and October and was submitted for the State acceptance tests on 18 November. However, flight testing was interrupted by the need to replace the engine between 17 December 1942 and 26 January 1943. The new engine failed the next day and the aircraft crashed on 27 January. Flight tests were ordered to be continued with the original prototypes to validate the range figures, but the first prototype crashed on 5 April, killing the pilot as he attempted a dead-stick landing.
All work to put the I-185 into production was cancelled afterwards, even with the M-82 engine, as they were all required for the La-5 fighter. Another reason cited was that the La-5 used the fuselage of the Lavochkin-Gorbunov-Goudkov LaGG-3 which was already in production in three plants and would involve less disruption of the production lines. Another factor may have been that the La-5 required less duralumin to build, something in short supply at the time.
This is not the first 1/72 injected I-185 to be produced as Model Russia did one back many years ago that came in a header bag. I have one somewhere and will preview it if I can find it. I'm pretty sure that this is not the same kit as what is offered by Art Model. Art Model's kit is molded on two sprues of mostly white plastic with a clear sprue for the one-piece canopy and landing light cover. It also comes with a superbly molded resin engine that will be pretty well hidden away in the cowling behind a rather large spinner.
Overall, the molding of the kit is quite good. As the airframe is mostly made of wood, there are not a ton of panel lines. The kit does display some flash on parts and parts 9 and 10 (interior side consoles) do have some rather prominent sink areas on them, though they probably won't be seen once the model is finished.
There is a very prominent sprue run on the trailing edge of the upper left wing half. The instructions point this out so the folks at Art Model are aware of it. It will have to be sanded down prior to assembly. I like that the two horizontal stabs and the tail cone are a single piece as this eases alignment. It will be interesting to see how this builds up. Cockpit is well appointed with a floor, seat, stick, instrument and side panels. Two sets of decals are available for the panels and both seem to be exactly the same. There are two pieces to be used to mostly box in the main wheel wells.
Instructions are well printed on glossy paper and include several of what look to be photos of the kit in various stages of constructions with numbers pointing to the various pieces. As this is not a complex kit, this method is more than adequate. No interior or wheel well or gear leg colors are provided. There is a markings and painting scheme for one plane that is olive green over light blue. Two Humbrol numbers are provided for these colors. The small decal sheet looks to be well printed.
It is a shame that this aircraft was never produced as I'm sure it would have been quite successful. I'm thinking this may be the M-71 powered plane, but as I've not a lot of info on the plane, I'm not positive. Regardless, the kit looks to be fairly simple and though not really flamboyant in terms of markings, will make into a nice addition to any 1/72 Soviet fighter collection.
March 2011 Thanks to
for the preview kit. Get yours at the link and at a discount. If you would like your product reviewed fairly and quickly, please
me or see other details in the
Contributors. Back to the Main Page
Back to the Previews Index Page
Thanks to www.scale-model-kits.com for the preview kit. Get yours at the link and at a discount.
If you would like your product reviewed fairly and quickly, please contact me or see other details in the Note to Contributors.
Back to the Main Page
Back to the Previews Index Page